How far will medicine go in becoming the great corporate beast in
American culture. Presently our entire medical scheme is changing. Who
makes the decision on what is "good" medicine and what is "bad"
medicine is being slowly taken out of the hands of doctors and put into
the hands, well not real hands, of a computer. Software guidelines
maker Milliman has gained credibility in creating objective evidence
based guidelines which are being used by the government (CMS). For the
average person their reaction is usually "so?".
We don't really know, as citizens, who is making all the decisions
about what is paid for by Medicare or Medicaid and who gets what
benefit? Let me tell you who is pulling the strings: a computer owned
and programmed by a private company called Milliman. The Milliman
computer is advertised as an "objective" method of making decisions.
Maybe that's true, but I'm skeptical.
They say medicine is an art not a science. I do believe that is
true. Right now doctors fight hard to keep control of what care their
patient receives. They say you need to evaluate the objective evidence
but also known the patient and really listen to what another human
being tells you is going on. Some in the scientific community think
that sounds hokey.
In the scientific world the hard fact reason works better. There
best argument is that it's their butt on the line when something bad
happens. If they mess up and make negligent decisions they are held
accountable (that means they are sued).
Here are two interesting positions converging. Insurance companies
and government both want control over treatment decisions, and doctors
want to escape liability. The obvious solution is to provide doctors
immunity from responsibility for treatment outcomes as long as they
follow what the government computer tells them is the "objective based"
medical decision. Eventually we can rid ourselves of doctors for
really smart computers.
I'm sure lawyers will continue working for big companies who use
litigation as a tool to stop or financially bury small innovative start
ups and other small businessmen (most of whom will deserve what they
get for supporting tort reform in the first place.)
No comments:
Post a Comment